Is Michael Phelps the greatest American athlete? He’s unquestionably the greatest olympian… But I am asking you if this goofy bastard is the greatest athlete to EVER compete in any sport? He’s got to be Top 5, right?
He certainly is one of the ugliest.

I just don’t know… I respect everything he’s accomplished in the pool, but I always picture my idea of the “greatest athlete” as someone who would probably be good at anything he or she tried.
— SIDEBAR: I’m not sure why in the above sentence I felt compelled to write “he or she”. With all apologies to the descendants of Babe Zaharias, but I think while we may disagree which individual is the greatest athlete of all time, I think we can all agree that every candidate in the argument has a set of testicles… Well, maybe not Lance Armstrong with his “uni-ball”, but you get my point. —
Michael Jordan, Bo Jackson, Deion Sanders… Guys like that would’ve probably excelled in any sport they dedicated their lives to. But I think Phelps was built to be a fish, and that’s it. Plus, I watched a couple of his events, and I didn’t see a single black guy in the pool. So his degree of competition is “suspect” to say the least.
In the end, I’m putting him #4, behind Jordan, Jim Thorpe, and Kevin Duckworth.
Take a report.
-Large